>>
|
No. 199
>>197
You misunderstand, I'm not saying the technique is ineffective, I'm saying it's not necessary for a completely new learner. The "throw them into the deep end" approach might work, but there's other ways to learn how to swim that are a lot less traumatizing, or frustrating in the case of learning a language. You can try and drive a car with your feet, and if you really try you could be a great driver. Total immersion from day one could work, but a much better way is to learn the basics of the language, build up your vocabulary and kanji knowledge through daily speaking and writing study, then once you are confident enough that you might be able to walk through the streets of Tokyo and interact with people, you can do that or try and get as close as you can to the real thing at home.
That doesn't mean immersion can't be put in as part of the learning process, playing Japanese games, watching anime and live action Japanese shows/movies without subtitles, listening to Japanese music are all good things to do once you feel comfortable with it, but that's the key. Making it as enjoyable as you can and building confidence, not forcing yourself to learn the language out of necessity. That's how people locked up in Chinese prisons learn the language, but it probably wouldn't make many of them that enthusiastic about it.
But hey, if that's what you WANT to do, then go ahead and knock yourself out. Everyone learns a different way, after all. Some people might find it hard to get motivated to learn a language another way, so they frustrate themselves into forcing themselves to learn it. I'm just saying there could be better ways to learn it for others.
|