-  [JOIN IRC!]


[Return]
Posting mode: Reply
Name
Subject   (reply to 480)
Message
File
Password  (for post and file deletion)
¯\(°_O)/¯
  • Supported file types are: BMP, GIF, JPG, PNG
  • Maximum file size allowed is 1000 KB.
  • Images greater than 400x400 pixels will be thumbnailed.
  • Currently 179 unique user posts. View catalog

  • Blotter updated: 2023-01-12 Show/Hide Show All

File 132908301052.jpg - (71.92KB , 500x390 , EndersGame.jpg )
480 No. 480
I just finished Ender's Game. I loved it. However I just found out they are making a movie that comes out in 2013. I fucking hate child actors. I don't know if I can get excited about it.

What are your feelings on it? As long as they don't go hollywood on it and get some kids that I can deal with (unlikely) I can see myself seeing it.
>> No. 481
ahh, lucky you, i went through the audiobook version, and at the end Orson Card talks about this very topic

iunno go look through some torrents and hope you get lucky
>> No. 482
I liked the book, the rest of the series is much better. I'm always happy to see good science fiction books made into movies, but I'm fairly pessimistic about this one.
>> No. 533
I'm not the type to get all super excited and hyped about any movie adaptation of books I like. I'll see it and if it's good I'll be thrilled and if it's not good then I won't be bummed. It's not like the quality of the movie affects the quality of the book, so whatever.

I know what you mean about child actors though. They can be really hit and miss and are almost always miss. They might luck out though and get some awesome child actors, which happens every so often...

>>482
The only other book in the series I really liked was Speaker. Xenocide was alright but nothing great. Children of the Mind I didn't even bother finishing. I've read Ender's Game like 5 or 6 times in the last 10 years and Speaker maybe 4 times and I've gotta say Ender's Game holds up the best. I was really moved by Speaker the first time I read it 8 or 9 years ago, but every time I reread Speaker I just feel more and more that the philosophical aspects of it are too goddamn heavy handed.

Ender's Game has a story that is simple and direct and doesn't get bogged down in philosophical noodling. It's just an engaging story, not a thought experiment or "vehicle" for intellectual noodling, and for that reason its message is the most clear, concise, and powerful. Speaker is certainly an engaging story, but has too much of a top-heavy "thought experiment" vibe for my liking... it most certainly is a vehicle for intellectual noodling and for that reason is less tight and feels like Card tried too hard to turn what could have been a solid mystery/suspense story with some interesting relationships between the characters into an allegory.

Xenocide had that problem in fucking spades...

I don't know why I went off on this tirade, I just feel the exact opposite of you: I felt like the Ender series just gets weaker as it goes. Ender's Game is super tight and engaging and that makes it the most effective to me. Everything after that gets a bit forced and more about Card pushing shoveling an allegory at the reader rather than just telling a compelling story and letting the story speak for itself and letting the reader draw their own conclusions.


Delete post []
Password  
Report post
Reason